Never be ashamed of having a crush on Benny Agbayani I'm a crusher
Baseball player
Votes | Ranking | Boost Ranking | |
---|---|---|---|
![]() |
![]() |
Benny Agbayani ranks
, and ranks
among all celebrities on
.



Benny Agbayani is straight and has been downright flaming -- he is breaking our gaydar! Don't get me wrong but the manliest men often have man-crushes on effeminate men. It makes them feel even more manly. Scroll down and check out his short and medium hairstyles.
2 Ways to Vote him Up!
1. Hit the "X Post" button at the top ↑2. Tell us "why you have a crush on him"
Refresh this page to see the "Crushers" increase after you "Like" or vote.
Why People Have A Crush On Benny Agbayani
50+ man-crushers
Rated by - The 1st baseball card I ever had was Benny Agbayani and I thought he was the greatest player ever for a little while lmfao. -- David
- And who can forget Benny Agbayani? The Eastern League champion 94 B-Mets ended up having more than a few players on the 2000 WS Mets. -- Nathan Wurtzel
- Benny Agbayani! -- Evan Altman
- I saw Benny Agbayani -- James Pollitt
- Now you guys know how I felt when Benny Agbayani retired. -- Will Stegemann
- Jeter dreamed of the career of Benny Agbayani. -- Mr Solo Dolo
- Benny Agbayani and Admiral Ackbar IMO -- Isaac Lopez
- Benny Agbayani got married just before AAA All-Star game in Norfolk in '98 maybe '99 -- Jason Wise
- Wait you're not Benny Agbayani?! from far away, you look like Benny agbayani. -- jojo
- Or the guy who ate benny agbayani, amirite? from far away, you look like Benny agbayani. -- Marc Carig
- from far away, you look like Benny agbayani. -- ...........
- ooooooooooo Benny Agbayani, The Hawaiian Punch! Awesome! -- Damon Pappas
- Shea Stadium 2008 playoff game vs Giants, Benny Agbayani hit series ending HR, Upper Deck was shaking like earthquake -- Mike Dietrich
- haha maybe he's second to Benny Agbayani -- Richard J Nardo
- about as happy as I get watching Benny Agbayani hit a homerun! L I love champagne more then the mets -- restaurant north
- Ok I also miss Benny Agbayani. Him and Shinjo. Who do you miss? -- Joe DeMayo
- Like Todd Pratt & Benny Agbayani, Travis Ishikawa's whole MLB career is now justified. -- Dan McLaughlin
- You know who I miss... Benny Agbayani. Guy was a klutz in the OF but a whoot to watch. -- Anthony Powell
- Benny Agbayani -- Roger Podacter
- Not since Met Benny Agbayani has a Honolulu guy tormented the like Kolten Wong. His 2-run triple cuts lead to 4-2. -- Emil Guillermo
- Most HR, born in Hawaii: Sphincterino 108 Mike Lum 90 Kurt Suzuki 75 Benny Agbayani 39 Lenn Sakata 25 Kolten Wong 23 Joey Meyer 18 -- High Heat Stats MLB
- I miss when baseball was fun, when Timo Perez stole bases and Benny Agbayani had actual, authentic hype surrounding him. -- Ethan Hammerman
- Postseason walk off homeruns: Benny Agbayani: Game 3, 2000 NLDS Todd Pratt: Game 4, 1999 NLDS Lenny Dykstra: Game 3, 1986 NLCS -- New York Mets Stats
- KOLTEN WONG BENNY AGBAYANI -- Ethan
- Better baseball name: Benny Agbayani or Andres Galarraga? -- Ben Bowman
- Benny agbayani, jay payton wow that mets lineup was ummm special -- Greg
- Anyone else remember Benny Agbayani giving a kid a game used ball then taking it back because there were only two outs? -- Майкл
- Benny Agbayani was the original Flying Hawaiian -- Mike Viglietta
- About to order my Benny Agbayani Mets jersey. -- Mike Barba
- I think it is time to break out the old Benny Agbayani T-shirt jersey. -- Harry Hadlock III
- What in the name of he is going on at Citi Field?! -- Jonah N
- Bring back benny agbayani -- αѕѕвυтт
- The starting outfield in 2000 was Derek Bell, Jay Payton, and Benny Agbayani. -- The Real Danny Latin
- Maybe the need to bring back Benny Agbayani or Butch Husky. How about the untouchable prospect Fernando Martinez! -- Joe Duffy
- Spotted: A Benny Agbayani Jersey -- Christina C
- Conforto wearing Looks a little like a left-handed Benny Agbayani. Big boy. -- Robert Brender
- Hoping for a Benny Agbayani (THE GAWD) cameo in ALOHA. -- Marko Orlic
- 5. Ricky Otero (-0.9 WAR), 4. Mike Jacobs (-2.4 WAR), 3. Jason Phillips (-1.7), 2. Benny Agbayani (1.3 WAR), Vance Wilson (3.8 WAR) -- Alex Nelson
- Benny Agbayani talk going on in the office right now. It must be summer. -- Rhett Manuel
- " what comes around goes around " - coach benny agbayani -- кαуℓєє иαкαмυяα
- Any more retreads the could try before actually spending on a major league hitter? What's Benny Agbayani doing? -- Jonathan
- George is Benny Agbayani and Sal is John Kruk IMHO -- Michael Donohue
- This kid Chris really has the Benny Agbayani jersey on -- Woedell Beckham
- This week I've spoken to Bobby Jones and met Benny Agbayani. What is this, the turn of the century? -- Robbie Rosenhaus
- Benny Agbayani sighting in the dugout... -- Michael Baron
- Most often-remembered guys being remembered right now in my timeline (unofficial count): Archi Cianfrocco, Benny Agbayani, Mackey Sasser. -- Ken Tremendous
- Whats Benny Agbayani doing these days??? -- Luis Mingo
- If Franchise 4 epitomizes a team then for the it should be Benny Agbayani, Timo Perez, Tsuyoshi Shinjo & Armando (either 1 u pick) -- SevoMD
- Guy walking out of ahead of me had a Benny Agbayani shirt on. -- Kate Feldman
- Found my old Mets hat from the Benny Agbayani era of bandwagoning. Good times. Maybe they'll make the playoffs -- Nathan Ham
Body:
Face:
Mind:
Heart: