Jay Cutler

Never be ashamed of having a crush on Jay Cutler
American football quarterback
Votes Ranking Boost Ranking
Jay Cutler ranks Loading, and ranks Loading among all celebrities on the Top Celebrity Crushes list.

Jay Cutler is straight and is pretty "gay". Just a friendly reminder: don't be ashamed to admit that you have a crush on him. He has light brown hair. Scroll down and check out his athletic body, short and/or medium light brown hairstyles & haircuts.

2 Ways to Vote him Up!

1. Hit the "Tweet" button at the top ↑
2. Tell us "why you have a crush on him"
Refresh this page to see the "Crushers" increase after you "Like" or vote.

Why People Have A Crush On Jay Cutler

new! Rate Jay Cutler


Average: 6 (1 vote)


Average: 9 (1 vote)


Average: 3 (1 vote)


Average: 10 (1 vote)
Minimum 15 Words.
More votes will improve the ranking in Hottest Celebrities, and your comment will appear at the top. You'll be redirected to PayPal for the transaction.
3 star rating
Rated by 50+ man-crushers
  • 1 star rating Including playoffs, Jay Cutler has lost 7 straight starts vs Packers and is 1-9 against them since joining Bears in 09 --
  • 3 star rating Aaron Rodgers told everyone to relax because Aaron Rodgers remembered who he is. --
  • 5 star rating Last night I dreamt Tannehill accumulated 52 fantasy points on a fluke, but i d played Jay Cutler instead. My subconscious is losing it. --
  • 5 star rating "Jay Cutler wanted to come because he figured Shanahan was coming anyhow, and so he wanted to come, too." -Former Redskins VP Vinny Cerrato --
  • 5 star rating Cutler to Redskins? QB thought so in 2009: Chicago Bears quarterback Jay Cutler on Monday confirmed a recent report he was nearly a m... --
  • 5 star rating He is in the UK --
  • 5 star rating He is suspect af as a qb, so overrated I think --
  • 2 star rating Jay Cutler has better chemistry with Landry than Tannehill lmao. He really gave him his best season. --
  • 4 star rating Jay cutler is the best idol you could have for bodybuilding!! --
  • 5 star rating He is sooooo overrated. --
  • 3 star rating He is still 2nd in the league in passing TDs. We (our offense) is fine --
  • 5 star rating Not trying to disrespect Dennis Allen, He came out here and coached a team nobody wanted to, So I thank him for that but it's time to move o --
  • 5 star rating Chris Christie stumping for Scott Walker is the equivalent of Jay Cutler quarterbacking for the Chicago Bears. Burke and Packers win. --
  • 1 star rating The face I want to see before i die is the babyface of the son of Eli Manning's dumb face and Jay Cutler's cryface --
  • 4 star rating Jay Cutler for Jamaal Charles is the trade of the century. --
  • 1 star rating Jay Cutler just throws another 2nd half pick 6. Wait. What's that? Tom Brady did it? BREAKING: Tom Brady is Cutlering. --
  • 5 star rating Brady swears he is jay cutler --
  • 5 star rating "he is SAWFT" sign wins the night --
  • 4 star rating Tom Brady is making the Jay Cutler game on Sunday look not so bad. --
  • 5 star rating Is Jay playing for New England tonight?? --
  • 5 star rating Wow Brady really is trying to be Jay Cutler --
  • 4 star rating Tom Brady is taking a few plays out of Jay Cutler's book lol --
  • 5 star rating Jay Cutler > Tom Brady this season so far --
  • 5 star rating The sad part is that this is supposed to be the "easier" stretch. Good luck against Aaron Rodgers, Peyton Manning, Jay Cutler, etc etc etc --
  • 3 star rating He is coming to Cardiff? Almost certainly going to have to go to that! --
  • 4 star rating Luke Bryan and Jay Cutler should be brothers they are just so fine --
  • 1 star rating Jay Cutler's 8 TD passes through the 1st three games is the most in franchise history. He surpassed Sid Luckman's 7. --
  • 4 star rating Stat of the day: he is 1-9 all-time against the Green Bay Packers. --
  • 5 star rating All those who critique Jay Cutler for his personality are the same people who love Aaron Rodgers because he is so personable. NO HE ISNT --
  • 4 star rating He is going to come through for me since its Peyton's bye week. --
  • 5 star rating He is the frattiest quarterback in the league --
  • 2 star rating During his time in Chicago, he is 7-1 with 16 TD's, 3 Int's and a QB rating of 99.7 on Monday Night Football. --
  • 5 star rating He is Tony Romo of the midwest --
  • 1 star rating Donovan McNabb said he is the Tony Romo of the Midwest? Well, at least that's better than the Donovan McNabb of the planet Earth --
  • 5 star rating If he is slonking eggs I am slonking eggs --
  • 3 star rating My mom just said he is more attractive than Aaron Rodgers.... Who do you think you are --
  • 4 star rating I guess John Fox is going to make Jay Cutler good at football. --
  • 1 star rating Is it weird that I totally am curious as to what type of a dad Jay Cutler would be? I mean was he even happy to be one? --
  • 4 star rating Today in class this kid said jay cutler is the best overall QB. --
  • 1 star rating From Short Takes: "NFL Player Befuddled by Microsoft Surface Tablets." Sure. But he is befuddled by a 4-3 defense too. --
  • 4 star rating That play is why it's hard to give up on Jay Cutler. --
  • 3 star rating Whenever I see Jay Cutler on TV, all I can think about is his League episode. --
  • 4 star rating Thing is, jay cutler never figured it out.. Just saying --
  • 5 star rating If he is a champion tomorrow, sure --
  • 5 star rating "he is so Yankees." --
  • 4 star rating quarterback Bo Wallace is legit the next Vandy Jay Cutler. --
  • 5 star rating Bo Wallace is jay cutler --
  • 4 star rating Jameis Winston is doing a great Jay Cutler impression --
  • 5 star rating Jay cutler is underrated af too --
  • 3 star rating You know how hard it is to have a TD-INT of -50 like Joe Namath's? Jay Cutler's TD/INT is +50! --

Throwback Thursday #TBT

jay cutler bears 0.jpg
jay cutler football player 1.jpg
jay cutler and kristin cavallari 2.jpg
Jay Cutler new pic 3.jpg
jay cutler baby 4.jpg
jay cutler and kristin cavallari 5.jpg
jay cutler baby 6.jpg
jay cutler wife 7.jpg
Jay Cutler sexy 8.jpg
Jay Cutler new pic 9.jpg
jay cutler wife 10.jpg
jay cutler nfl 11.jpg